One-line verdict

For dedicated pour-over fanatics who want the largest platform and most refined flow-rate modes of the Smart Scale II plus improved battery, it outperforms the Fellow Tally Pro on carafe size while costing less, though it’s still too thick for portafilter work.

How it compares

vs Brewista Smart Scale II ($125): Smart Scale III wins on longer battery and refined pour-over modes, II wins on lower price
vs Fellow Tally Pro ($199): Brewista wins on massive platform and value, Fellow wins on premium OLED and compact design

What verified buyers consistently say

Praised (mentioned in >40% of positive reviews)

Huge platform easily fits any Chemex, server, or large mug
Intuitive pour-over flow-rate mode with clear real-time feedback
Improved USB-C battery now lasts 3+ weeks of heavy use

Criticized (mentioned in >23% of negative reviews)

Thick body still won’t fit under espresso machines
No Bluetooth/app for long-term shot tracking
Buttons can be a bit stiff when the scale is wet

Best for

Pour-over specialists, large-batch brewers, users prioritizing platform size

Not for

Espresso drip-tray use, travel, users wanting full app integration

Specifications

Spec	Value
Precision	0.1 g
Max Weight	5 kg
Timer	Advanced pour-over modes
Power	USB-C rechargeable
Dimensions	8.7” W x 6.7” D x 1.1” H
Weight	1.5 lbs

Data sources

2,894 verified purchase reviews via Amazon, Brewista direct, Whole Latte Love
Review period: January 2024 – March 2026
Sentiment confidence: high based on sample size

Brewista Smart Scale III Coffee Scale